Romantic Anniversary Dinner Spots in Garden City, NY

An anniversary dinner deserves a room that feels intentional — good light, a wine list worth exploring, and a pace that lets the evening unfold instead of rushing through it. Novità was built with exactly that kind of night in mind: an elevated Italian wine bar in the heart of Garden City with 100 wines by the glass, so there's always something new to try together.

For couples who want something a little more special, our intimate booths offer a more intimate tasting experience — a smaller, more personal setting where the kitchen can walk you through a menu built around the seasons. It's a favorite request for milestone anniversaries, where the meal itself becomes part of the celebration.

If you'd rather stay in the main dining room, our wine bar atmosphere still offers plenty of romance — warm lighting, an approachable but serious wine program, and a full Italian menu that rewards sharing a few plates over the course of the evening.

However you'd like to celebrate, we're happy to help make the night feel a little more considered — from a specific wine pairing to a quiet table for two. Explore our wine tasting experiences or reach out to plan your evening